British Meat Processors Association
British Meat Processors Association
BMPA Conference 2019 discussion panel

BMPA Conference delivers a blunt reality check on post-Brexit trade deals

We were told to expect straight-talk at this year’s BMPA Conference, which the headline speakers certainly delivered on, and delegates were given a lot more than lunch to chew over.

Rather than listening to our UK politicians putting their spin on Brexit and Britain’s prospects for international trade, we enlisted Bill Westman of the North American Meat Institute and Lars Hoelgaard of the international consultancy TradeUp to ‘tell it how it is’, first from a US and then from an EU perspective.

Bill Westerman - BMPA Conference 2019
Bill Westman talks about a US trade deal

Bill Westman was keen to emphasise that the US wants to work with the UK and sees ‘big opportunities around Brexit’, but it became clear that this cooperation would come at a price. Part of that price, Mr Westman explained, is that the US ‘must have meaningful market access through the elimination or reduction of all import duties and tariff-rate quotas’.

He went on to say that America doesn’t want to ask the UK to change its system, but it does want to ask us to not restrict trade in goods that are ‘internationally approved’. In practice, however, that would mean changing UK standards to allow currently banned products into the country.

Lars Hoelgaard put it more bluntly: ‘You’re going to take some hormone beef, some chlorinated chicken and some GMOs’ in order to do a deal with Trump’s America. He also cautioned that we’d be giving up 50% of our trade (currently with the EU) in favour of chasing after some ‘marginal, perhaps non-existent’ trade with the US. ‘Is this what you want?’ asked Mr Hoelgaard.

Lars Hoelgaard - BMPA Conference 2019
Lars Hoelgaard provides a blunt reality check to delegates

Later in the panel discussion, Peter Hardwick, BMPA’s Trade Policy Advisor, emphasised that there is no way of knowing just how the meat industry will be traded-off against other key industries in future trade negotiations with third countries like the US. Trade deals are about compromise and there will be no ‘easy deals’ to be done.

But it was Lars Hoelgaard who delivered the most jarring commentary on the UK’s prospects in the event of a hard Brexit, which we’ll devote a separate article to shortly. Suffice it to say, if what he warned us about starts to play out, the top priority for BMPA will be to work with our own politicians and civil servants to equip them with the right understanding of this industry and the unintended consequences of making the wrong negotiating decisions.

Unless Brexit is cancelled or we agree on some form of customs union and harmonised regulations and standards, we should prepare for a bumpy ride.

About BMPA

The British Meat Processors Association (BMPA) is the leading trade association for the meat and meat products industry in the UK.

Latest

pencil erasing the UK's EU membership

Bordering on the ridiculous – Managing the UK’s autonomous beef tariff rate quota

The title isn’t original I know but it aptly describes...

map of Ireland

The Irish Border – Implications for the meat industry

Arrangements surrounding the Irish border post-Brexit have the potential to...

eggs in a box

Keep your friends close and your neighbours closer

I asked in my article ‘It Takes WTO to Tango’...

Beef cattle

The truth behind UK beef prices – do we have an unsustainable supply chain?

There has been much talk recently about low farmgate beef...

If you want an 'I didn't know that!' moment, have a listen to what @JoannaBlythman has to say (at 35mins) on the origins of veganism and the hidden environmental and human costs of eating certain foods like jackfruit and avocado.

This makes a lot of sense. The danger at the moment is that people's decisions are being driven by headline-grabbing claims flying around in the media and on social media, many of which are either factually incorrect or taken out of context.
We need a balanced, fact-based debate

Starting in 20 minutes at 9:30am. This is an important discussion with the right mix of people at the table to get a balanced view of what's happening.