Pig Sector: BMPA Pork Supply Chain Report

British Meat Processors Association
British Meat Processors Association

Theresa May’s ‘three baskets’ amounts to cherry picking says EU

Teresa May’s much vaunted speech on 2 March brought at last some much needed realism regarding Brexit. This includes the realisation that there will be a “significant reduction” of market access.

However, the speech includes whole baskets of cherries freshly picked from the tree. In practice, the UK now banks on three ‘baskets’: one regarding trade with no regulatory divergence such as car parts as part of a supply chain, this would include competition laws, another with “managed divergence” such as the environment or animal welfare and a third with full divergence, which would include agriculture and fisheries.    

This formulation and the aim of reciprocity of regulatory standards is illusionary and is rejected by the EU who will not compromise its decision-making autonomy. One cannot have ‘its cake and eat it”, in other words, leave the club, enjoy its benefit and make the rules – in EU speak “have the same rights and enjoy the same benefits”. This certainly applies to the international meat trade.

We have little to gain from regulatory divergence (meaning in practice further gold-plating of environment and animal welfare legislation) and lots to lose in terms of trade.

The European Council, the instance representing the EU-27 governments, gave its opinion on 7 March. This important document shows glimpses of the end game. As press commentator Martin Schulz says “the likelihood is that the UK will exit on terms laid down, in details, by the EU”.

On a very welcome note for British meat exporters, potentially exposed to punishing tariffs, the draft guidelines clearly state that no tariff should apply to the trade of goods between the UK and the EU, an opinion also expressed in Mrs Mays’ speech. The document talks of a new Free Trade Agreement and dismisses frictionless trade, meaning the return of veterinary and other controls at borders’ posts.

Coming back to the ‘three baskets’ theory, one must mention the Brexit report of the Institute of Directors that endorses such solution. Slightly different from Government’s views, it discounts a trade agreement for agricultural commodities, probably perceived as too complex to negotiate. This would be indeed a vexing outcome for our industry.

Of course, despite the welcome new clarity on Brexit, everything remains in the realm of the possible. For instance, the intractable Irish border issue may still derail negotiations. For the moment, we can glimpse what the future outside the EU will look like.

The views expressed in this article may not reflect the policies of the BMPA

Jean-Pierre Garnier

About Jean-Pierre Garnier

Jean-Pierre is CEO of Meatwise International a marketing, strategic and technical consultancy for the meat production chain. Prior to Meatwise, Jean-Pierre was Head of Exports at AHDB for 13 years.


Why Suella Braverman’s remedy for the labour crisis won’t work

In an ideal world there would, as the Home Secretary...

Pigs on a farm

BMPA report says Defra’s pork supply chain consultation needs to look wider

BMPA's members sit at the centre of the British meat...

BMPA - Trade body of the year 2022

BMPA wins Best Trade Association two years in a row

BMPA has won Best Trade Association for the second year...

CO2 gas bottles

Situation with Co2 supplies set to deteriorate markedly

This week the security of UK Co2 supplies to critical...

The government has listened to meat industry warnings and pushed this plan back 12 months — more reality in face of post-#brexit regulatory enforcement capacity constraints.

https://britishmeatindustry.org/updates/defra-agree-to-move-new-rule-deadline-by-one-year/ https://twitter.com/pmdfoster/status/1587000818875744264

Huge relief that Defra has agreed to postpone new export rules by one year.
But there's still work to be done, and BMPA is looking forward to working with them to help devise a new system that's going to be needed to implement the new rules successfully.

This leaked letter from George Eustice comes as no surprise. But what else are we currently capitulating on?

Our warnings about the Oz trade deal went unheeded

Other countries have sector experts inside the tent during negotiations.....The UK doesn't.