British Meat Processors Association
British Meat Processors Association

Report in top peer reviewed medical journal debunks health scare about red meat

The American College of Physicians has published in their journal ‘Annals of Internal Medicine’ a ‘study of studies’ that reviewed the entire body of work that has been carried out in this area. This new review exposes evidence from previous studies linking meat with cancer as ‘weak’ and only ‘able to provide low or very low certainty in their conclusions’.

Based on the most comprehensive review of evidence to date, the bottom line is that reducing red meat could have little or no effect on whether or not an individual goes on to develop cardiovascular disease or cancer.

The findings expose a number of flaws in how these studies were conducted and point out that ‘many studies selectively report results’. This is highlighted by the fact that two studies working from exactly the same data sets manage to reach opposite conclusions with one reporting a ‘significant risk’ and the other reporting no health risk.

The findings expose a number of flaws in how these studies were conducted and point out that ‘many studies selectively report results’.

Part of the problem has been how those studies were conducted. Most were observational which means they were based on notoriously unreliable self-reports of food consumption. Many didn’t take into account other lifestyle factors that may have an equal or greater impact on health.

For example, would someone who consumes a quarter pounder every day be more likely to accompany that with fries and a sugary drink instead of fruit and water? What other lifestyle habits like smoking and drinking alcohol is that same person also likely to have?

Nick Allen, CEO of the British Meat Processors Association commented: ‘This report highlights a gap in the evidence from scientific studies. Instead of flawed observational studies, dietary advice should be based on higher quality randomised control trials that compare differing but strictly controlled amounts of red meat consumption over a long time frame. To date, only twelve have been carried out, none of which offer any conclusive or even consistent evidence.’

Commenting on how this affects consumers, Mr Allen added: ‘It raises questions about how dietary advice is communicated to people. Official guidelines based on evidence with ‘low to very low certainty’ coupled with headline-grabbing but unsubstantiated claims in the media and on social media are not helpful.

‘It prompts some people to make drastic changes to their diet without having an accurate picture of how this will affect their health. These people run the risk of inadvertently substituting a healthy, balanced diet with one that lacks essential nutrients and has the opposite effect on their health.’

About BMPA

The British Meat Processors Association (BMPA) is the leading trade association for the meat and meat products industry in the UK.

Latest

Process line workers

New BMPA report offers solutions to workforce challenges

The problem of labour shortages in the meat industry is...

Lorry on the motorway

Britain hasn’t exported to Europe for 46 years – but we’re about to start

Most people think that the UK currently ‘exports’ goods to...

Neon cancelled sign

Exporters will start losing EU orders within 12 weeks unless government provides clarity on trade arrangements

British meat companies will start losing orders from EU customers...

Meat plant workers

Government needs to act to fix the shortage of skilled butchers

The British meat processing industry is facing a shortage of...

The campaign to keep lower-standard meat out of Britain after Brexit is still going strong backed by @jamieoliver.
You can also listen to Nick Allen discuss the technical side of how our new trade deals might work and the new Agriculture Bill here: https://bit.ly/3f2IWVi

Mark Morris from The Staff Canteen chairs a discussion on how a UK/US trade deal could impact the food we buy. Nick Allen gives the meat industry perspective and discusses 'the elephant in the room' - the structure of UK agriculture.
https://bit.ly/3f2IWVi
@CanteenTweets @Chef1

Unite the Union says working conditions within the #meat sector have contributed to an increase in #COVID19 cases, but according to BMPA, these claims are misleading and, in some cases, false. @BMPA_INFO @unitetheunion https://bit.ly/3eR9EjL